What has been troubling emerging markets?

Over the past 15 years or so GEM real GDP growth has, on average, been 3.2%1 higher than developed growth.

Schroders' Allan Conway, head of emerging market equities, takes a look at why global emerging markets have underperformed developed markets over the past three years, whether the trend will change and what has been discounted in equity markets

What has been troubling emerging markets?

What has been troubling emerging markets?

Why have global emerging markets underperformed? It is probably fair to say that many investors accept that the long-term structural case for emerging markets remains intact. Superior economic growth driven by favourable demographic trends and strong balance sheets means the centre of gravity of the global economy will continue to move towards the emerging world.

Over the past 15 years or so GEM real GDP growth has, on average, been 3.2%1 higher than developed growth. According to the International Monetary Fund this premium growth rate is expected to continue for the next five years at least. Furthermore, GEM has and continues to account for approximately 60-65% of global GDP growth. This is largely due to an acceleration of consumer spending and investment. In other words, it is a greater reliance on domestic consumption rather than simply exports to the West that is driving GEM growth.

Negative surprises

So why is the MSCI Emerging Markets index down 6% since the end of September 2010 when the MSCI World index is up 35% (both in US dollars)? Part of the explanation is that markets react to rates of change and expectations rather than to absolute levels. For the last three years GEM has struggled in this regard.

Both GDP and earnings have surprised on the downside in GEM but on the upside in developed. The main reason for this is that even though a disaster was avoided as we emerged from the financial crisis, investors were pessimistic about the prospects for the developed world and optimistic about GEM.

This was certainly correct in 2009. Growth in GEM rebounded sharply in response to massive stimulus but the developed recovery was, and remains, anaemic. The problem is that after the initial recovery, the anaemic developed world recovery has actually been better than those very negative expectations and the GEM growth rate has faded somewhat, particularly as China began to tighten in 2010. Growth surprises have been moving in opposite directions.

GEM earnings have also been relatively disappointing. Top-line revenue has fallen short of expectations and margins have been squeezed in the emerging world as costs, particularly wages, have increased. In the developed world, costs have been contained and margins have been maintained; for example, profits as a share of GDP in the US remain elevated. So GEM earnings have also underperformed versus developed and there is a close correlation between relative earnings and relative market performance.

A key reason for slower-than-expected growth in China has been the measures taken to rebalance the economy. It has been well documented that China needs to reduce dependence on fixed asset investment as a driver of growth and shift towards stronger consumption. The surprise has been that the new leadership appears to be pursuing this more aggressively than expected. As a result, demand for commodities has softened at a time when new supply is coming onto the market. Consequently the commodity producers in GEM have felt the impact.

The above trends have resulted in capital flowing from GEM to the developed world, and in particular to the US. As a consequence the trade-weighted US dollar has strengthened. This has put further pressure on GEM as a stronger dollar typically results in tighter policy settings in the emerging world.

Finally, comments from Ben Bernanke on May 22nd suggesting that the Federal Reserve Bank could begin tapering its quantitative easing programme in the not-too-distant future have negatively impacted those emerging countries reliant on short-term flows to fund large current account deficits. Despite a strong consensus that tapering would begin in September, this did not happen.

Attention has now switched to December but in the meantime GEM in general, and the countries with large current account deficits in particular, have rallied strongly. We believe this is just a short-term bounce and is not to be trusted. Near-term a number of headwinds remain. The structural problems in Europe are being addressed but progress is slow and issues could easily resurface.

The withdrawal of QE has been delayed but not cancelled and any aggressive unwinding of the significant emerging debt holdings built up by foreign investors could still be extremely disruptive for certain emerging equity markets.

Therefore our GEM portfolio continues to be cautiously positioned for now. The beta is a little below one and we are underweight deep cyclicals such as basic materials stocks.

What’s in the price

That’s the bad news. The good news is that much of the above has been reflected in market moves, which is why we are cautious rather than bearish. For example, looking at forward price to earnings ratios we find that the MSCI EM index is trading at around 10 times the next 12 months’ earnings. This is at a significant discount to both its history and to developed markets.

On a price to book (PB) basis we see the same large discount to history. The current PB ratio is around 1.5 times which is close to 1 standard deviation below the long run average of around 2 times.

While these valuations are not yet at rock-bottom levels, they are not too far away. Over the last 20 years or so emerging markets have traded at or above these levels 80-90% of the time. Moreover, on the few occasions when GEM has been below these levels, the returns over the following 12-36 months have always been strong.

In addition, as a result of the significant devaluation of the currencies of a number of countries running large current account deficits, the exporters in these countries are now much more competitive and better positioned to benefit from any recovery in global growth.

So where does that leave us? The answer is with the structural story intact, emerging markets continue to offer investors extremely attractive long-term investment opportunities, particularly given current valuation levels. The problem is that there remain a number of near-term headwinds and capital is, for now, flowing to the developed world. Consequently the rally in GEM over the last few weeks could easily fade.

But if investors take a longer-term view, gradually adding to GEM over the coming months could be very profitable – both in absolute terms and relative to developed markets.

Global Emerging Markets & Equity Release

What Is Equity Release?

Equity release is the use of financial arrangements that provide the owner of a house, or other property, with funds derived from the value of the property while enabling them to continue using it.

How Does Equity Release Work?

Equity release is aimed at homeowners aged 55 and over. It allows you to take some of the value of your home as cash.

Equity Release on Global Emerging Markets Equity

The Global Emerging Markets Equity Strategy is a diversified, core portfolio seeking to identify growing countries and the companies that could potentially benefit. In our integrated process, we translate macro thematic research and fundamental bottom-up analysis into a growth-oriented portfolio. We take a thematic approach to help identify longer-term trends not fully appreciated by the market and construct a diversified portfolio of 100 to 125 stocks we believe are positioned to benefit from the future drivers of growth in emerging markets.

Editorial Note: This content has been independently collected by the EveryInvestor advisor team and is offered on a non-advised basis. EveryInvestor may earn a commission on sales made from partner links on this page, but that doesn’t affect our editors’ opinions or evaluations. Learn more about our editorial guidelines.
Taylor Holt - 300x300

Written by
Taylor Holt
Estate Planning Expert

Taylor Is Our Resident Estate Planning Expert. He Knows That Everything Revolving Around Wills or Funeral Planning Can Be a Sensitive Subject That People Don’t Like to Discuss. But He Also Knows How Important It Is to Know All There Is to Know About It. Taylor Makes It His Mission to Spread Awareness About Estate Planning, and We Believe Everyinvestor Is the Best Platform to Do That.

Monique - 300x300

Written by
Monique Pittman
Pensions Expert

Monique Is Our Resident Pensions Expert. Many People Postpone Planning Out Their Pension, Thinking That Is Something They’ll Have to Worry Much Later in Life. Monique Knows How Important It Is to Start Planning Your Pension Early, and She Wants You to Know It Too!

Written by
Lisa Schilling
Insurance Expert

Lisa Is Our Resident Insurance Expert. She Knows How Important It Is to Be Ready for Any Scenario, Especially When a Family Member Is Involved. Nobody Likes Being Found Unprepared in a Tough Situation! Lisa Can Find the Best Insurance to Cover Your Every Need, Present and Future.

Doyle Edwards - 300x300

Written by
Doyle Edwards
Mortgages Expert

Doyle Is Our Resident Mortgages Expert. He Comes From a Long Line of Financial Gurus, and It Truly Shows. Despite His Young Age, There Is No Question He Cannot Answer When It Comes to Mortgages, and His Ability to See Outside of the Box to Find the Best Mortgage Deals Is Truly Impressive.

jason stubbs 300x300 1.jpg

Written by
Jason Stubbs
Equity Release Expert

Jason Stubbs Is a Specialist in the Equity Release Sector. He Enjoys Helping Older People Who Are Struggling Financially Get Out From Under Financial Pressure.

rachel w.jpg

Rachel Wait
Personal Finance Journalist

Rachel is an experienced finance journalist and editor with a particular interest in personal finance and consumer affairs. She has vast experience writing about money issues, property, insurance, and consumer affairs, and you’ll find her articles regularly featured in top media and newspaper publications.

Reviewed by
Francis Hui
Senior Risk Manager

Having held various high-level roles across the industry, Francis is truly an expert in aiding UK citizens in their financial decisions and risk analysis. His unique insight and statistical knowledge make him the perfect person to help you take your financial future to the next level.
Mark Patterson

Written by
Mark Patterson
Mortgage Expert

Mark Patterson is a well-known expert in mortgages. He has been working as an expert for over 15 years, and he specializes in the UK mortgage market.
kath icon.png

Katherine Read
Consumer Affairs Writer

She writes on the topics of equity release, home reversion, and mortgages.

Nicola Date

Nicola Date
Writer & Journalist

Nicola is a financial writer for EveryInvestor and is passionate about the opportunities that equity release can open up for homeowners. Her extensive business experience and deep understanding of the industry means that she’s always up-to-date with the latest developments.