Should I invest in commodities?

Precious metals such as gold and silver and industrial metals such as aluminium and copper are down 15.7% and 12.3% respectively while energy prices are up 4.5%.

Mouhammed Choukeir, chief investment officer at Kleinwort Benson, gives his view on the role of commodities in an investment portfolio.

Should I invest in commodities?

Should I invest in commodities?

Commodity markets have had a lacklustre start to the year. Overall, commodity prices are down 5.1% so far this year and are in negative momentum.

Precious metals such as gold and silver and industrial metals such as aluminium and copper are down 15.7% and 12.3% respectively while energy prices are up 4.5%.

Despite this recent weak performance commodities still have a role in multi asset portfolios but given the negative momentum, we now hold only a marginal allocation.

Getting over the hurdles

Investing in physical commodities has always presented three major obstacles: they do not generate income, they are difficult to value, and investors have to pay to store them, which eats away at the potential returns. So why invest in them?

Historically, the opportunity cost of investing in commodities has been high due to more favourable cash rates; given today’s low interest rate environment however this opportunity cost is now much lower.

Since 1945 the average cash rate has been 6.0%. It currently stands below 0.5%. Furthermore, although commodities cannot be valued using traditional methods, momentum-based strategies do provide a way to establish positive and negative trends.

Since 1991 a buy-and-hold strategy investing in commodities would have generated an annual return of approximately 4.8%. A momentum-based strategy, on the other hand, would have generated approximately 6.2% over the same period and with a lower level of volatility.

Finally although storage costs can be significant, they are factored into market prices and relative to price movement they can be comparatively small.

Although there are many risks to investing in commodities there are also many benefits.

First, owning commodities in multi asset portfolios offers beneficial portfolio diversification. Over the past five years some commodities have had a low or negative correlation to bonds and equities.

Second, commodity prices have a positive relationship with inflation. Since 1960, high and unexpected inflation has occurred nearly half the time and over those inflationary periods commodities have performed significantly better than equities and bonds.

Third, commodities continue to benefit from the economic growth in emerging markets. Energy consumption in Asia has been rising at 4% a year on average since 1990 and China, one of the fastest growing economies in the world, has been the largest global energy consumer since 2009; it now accounts for over a fifth of total energy consumption.

Changing the rules of the game

When it comes to global energy markets there is one elephant in the room that cannot be ignored: shale energy.

Shale is a non-porous rock that can be broken up by pumping in a mixture of water, sand and chemicals at high pressure to release trapped pockets of hydrocarbons (i.e., oil and gas).

Some pundits claim that the rapidly growing production of shale energy in the US is a game changer for global energy markets. Recent advancements in the extraction of energy from shale have led to an explosion in US oil and gas production.

Gas production has climbed by 30% since 2006, resulting in a dramatic decline in prices (from $13 per million Btu in 2008 to $4 currently).

Remarkably, the International Energy Agency expects the US to overtake Saudi Arabia as the biggest energy producer by 2017, and also predicts the US will be energy independent by 2035.

Promising as that may be, there remain major challenges ahead for the shale miracle. Extracting energy out of shale requires one to five million gallons of water per shale well, raising a significant environmental issue due to the potential for shale drilling to contaminate groundwater.

Another issue is that shale production is generally only suitable in areas of low population density, further limiting the opportunities.

Without a doubt, the emergence of shale-derived oil and gas will have a massive impact on the energy markets. However, it is impossible to predict what that outcome will be.

In energy markets, history is full of failed predictions. In the late 1990s, there was much media hype that the world was “drowning in oil” and that the oversupply would crush oil prices. That hype proved completely inaccurate: from the late 1990s, oil prices surged from $15 a barrel to $145 a barrel over the next ten years (a +866% increase). A key lesson from this is that basing investment decisions on hype and predictions is not a prudent way to invest.

Investment implications

Investing in commodities is risky. The average swing in prices since 1991 is 3% per month.

Commodities also suffered a large peak-to-trough loss of 54% during the credit crunch in 2008.

While that sounds like a bumpy ride, it is not too dissimilar to that experienced by investing in equities.

Irrespective of risk tolerance, preserving purchasing power should be the number one objective for all investors. That means if inflation rises, the value of investment portfolios should also rise in order to preserve purchasing power over the cycle.

As energy prices affect approximately 25% of the UK inflation basket, higher energy prices in turn lead to higher inflation. Therefore, owning commodities in multi asset portfolios helps to protect portfolios from unexpected higher inflation.

As such we would recommend holding a position, although recent negative momentum in commodities has led us to maintain a cautious view on the asset class. Should that momentum turn positive, we would look to increase our exposure.

Investing in Commodities & Equity Release

What Is Equity Release?

Equity release is the use of financial arrangements that provide the owner of a house, or other property, with funds derived from the value of the property while enabling them to continue using it.

How Does Equity Release Work?

Equity release is aimed at homeowners aged 55 and over. It allows you to take some of the value of your home as cash.

Equity Release Profit in Investing in Commodities

You’ll normally get between 20% and 60% of the market value of your home (or of the part you sell). When considering a home reversion plan, you should check: Whether or not you can release equity in several payments or in one lump sum. The minimum age at which you can take out a home reversion plan.

Editorial Note: This content has been independently collected by the EveryInvestor advisor team and is offered on a non-advised basis. EveryInvestor may earn a commission on sales made from partner links on this page, but that doesn’t affect our editors’ opinions or evaluations. Learn more about our editorial guidelines.
Taylor Holt - 300x300

Written by
Taylor Holt
Estate Planning Expert

Taylor Is Our Resident Estate Planning Expert. He Knows That Everything Revolving Around Wills or Funeral Planning Can Be a Sensitive Subject That People Don’t Like to Discuss. But He Also Knows How Important It Is to Know All There Is to Know About It. Taylor Makes It His Mission to Spread Awareness About Estate Planning, and We Believe Everyinvestor Is the Best Platform to Do That.

Monique - 300x300

Written by
Monique Pittman
Pensions Expert

Monique Is Our Resident Pensions Expert. Many People Postpone Planning Out Their Pension, Thinking That Is Something They’ll Have to Worry Much Later in Life. Monique Knows How Important It Is to Start Planning Your Pension Early, and She Wants You to Know It Too!

Written by
Lisa Schilling
Insurance Expert

Lisa Is Our Resident Insurance Expert. She Knows How Important It Is to Be Ready for Any Scenario, Especially When a Family Member Is Involved. Nobody Likes Being Found Unprepared in a Tough Situation! Lisa Can Find the Best Insurance to Cover Your Every Need, Present and Future.

Doyle Edwards - 300x300

Written by
Doyle Edwards
Mortgages Expert

Doyle Is Our Resident Mortgages Expert. He Comes From a Long Line of Financial Gurus, and It Truly Shows. Despite His Young Age, There Is No Question He Cannot Answer When It Comes to Mortgages, and His Ability to See Outside of the Box to Find the Best Mortgage Deals Is Truly Impressive.

jason stubbs 300x300 1.jpg

Written by
Jason Stubbs
Equity Release Expert

Jason Stubbs Is a Specialist in the Equity Release Sector. He Enjoys Helping Older People Who Are Struggling Financially Get Out From Under Financial Pressure.

rachel w.jpg

Rachel Wait
Personal Finance Journalist

Rachel is an experienced finance journalist and editor with a particular interest in personal finance and consumer affairs. She has vast experience writing about money issues, property, insurance, and consumer affairs, and you’ll find her articles regularly featured in top media and newspaper publications.

Reviewed by
Francis Hui
Senior Risk Manager

Having held various high-level roles across the industry, Francis is truly an expert in aiding UK citizens in their financial decisions and risk analysis. His unique insight and statistical knowledge make him the perfect person to help you take your financial future to the next level.
Mark Patterson

Written by
Mark Patterson
Mortgage Expert

Mark Patterson is a well-known expert in mortgages. He has been working as an expert for over 15 years, and he specializes in the UK mortgage market.
kath icon.png

Katherine Read
Consumer Affairs Writer

She writes on the topics of equity release, home reversion, and mortgages.

Nicola Date

Nicola Date
Writer & Journalist

Nicola is a financial writer for EveryInvestor and is passionate about the opportunities that equity release can open up for homeowners. Her extensive business experience and deep understanding of the industry means that she’s always up-to-date with the latest developments.