Should I commute part of my pension?

Would you want money dribbled out to you over your lifetime that is subject to income tax, or would you rather the money upfront with no tax?

One of the consistently most popular parts of the Barnett Waddingham website is the page that answers the question “what is commutation”?

Should I commute part of my pension?

Should I commute part of my pension?

This term, popularised by final salary pension schemes, is used to describe the act of exchanging pension income for tax-free cash. You may find it cropping up in such phrases as “you can commute part of your pension for a pension commencement lump sum”.

What do you mean by a pension commencement lump sum?

Well, that is simply a cash sum that can be paid to you when you pension starts, and currently it is tax-free.

Why do you say currently?

Because at least once a year there are calls for this tax-free benefit to be restricted either by taxing it to some extent or by drastically reducing the portion of your pension that you can swap for a tax-free cash sum.

Are the rules likely to be changed?

It is hard to say. Tax-free cash benefits higher rate tax payers the most and the sentiment is that it is fair to remove these apparent discrepancies. Yet at the same time we hear that only one in seven higher rate tax payers ends up paying higher rate tax when they get to retirement anyway so perhaps more damage will be done by removing a key reason why people save up in a pension.

So, if given the choice, I presume I should take the maximum offered to me as a tax-free cash sum?

This certainly seems the obvious answer: would you want money dribbled out to you over your lifetime that is subject to income tax, or would you rather the money upfront with no tax?

What complicated matters is that the final salary pension scheme sets the terms on which they reduce your pension for every £1 of tax-free cash you wish to take.

For example, you may be offered an annual pension of £15,000 or instead a tax-free lump sum of £69,230 with a lower pension of £10,385. Would you rather exchange £4,615 of taxable income for a tax-free lump sum of £69,230? Remember that the income that you give up may increase each year, for example by inflation.

Are these terms fair?

The trustees should set terms that are fair but they will be looking at fairness in relation to the entire scheme membership. Broadly, they would want simple terms that they can apply to the whole membership (and so do not take into account your own personal circumstances) and which would leave the scheme generally no worse off whichever route is taken by a member.

Why do my own personal circumstances count?

There are three key factors: how much tax you are likely to pay on your pension income, how long you are likely to live, and what investment return you would get if you had the lump sum to invest. Critically, all three factors are unknown as we do not know what future tax rates will be, how long we are going to live, or how much return we will get on money invested.

How do I decide?

You can take advice on the situation, which can look at your personal circumstances and expected outcomes but ultimately a view has to be taken.

Is it all about a financial assessment?

A financial assessment may reveal that it is better to have a taxed pension income for life than a tax-free cash sum. But human nature often means that the preference is to take the cash available to you when offered.

Anything else to be aware of?

Usually the tax-free cash is funded by reducing only your pension income. If your dependant has a pension payable on your death, this is usually unaffected but check your own scheme rules. Also, it is often the case that taking the tax-free cash means you will use up less of your pension lifetime allowance. This can be a useful way of managing the value of your pension rights if you are in danger of breaching the lifetime allowance.

If you are unsure, you can seek independent financial advice.

Pension & Equity Release

What Is Equity Release?

Equity release is the use of financial arrangements that provide the owner of a house, or other property, with funds derived from the value of the property while enabling them to continue using it.

How Does Equity Release Work?

Equity release is aimed at homeowners aged 55 and over. It allows you to take some of the value of your home as cash.

Tax on Equity Release Income

Dividends from shares held in a stocks and shares ISA or pension are tax-free. The tax rate you pay on dividends that exceed the allowance depends on your income tax band, which you can work out by adding your total dividend income to your other income: Basic rate taxpayers pay 7.5% Higher rate taxpayers pay 32.5%

Editorial Note: This content has been independently collected by the EveryInvestor advisor team and is offered on a non-advised basis. EveryInvestor may earn a commission on sales made from partner links on this page, but that doesn’t affect our editors’ opinions or evaluations. Learn more about our editorial guidelines.
Taylor Holt - 300x300

Written by
Taylor Holt
Estate Planning Expert

Taylor Is Our Resident Estate Planning Expert. He Knows That Everything Revolving Around Wills or Funeral Planning Can Be a Sensitive Subject That People Don’t Like to Discuss. But He Also Knows How Important It Is to Know All There Is to Know About It. Taylor Makes It His Mission to Spread Awareness About Estate Planning, and We Believe Everyinvestor Is the Best Platform to Do That.

Monique - 300x300

Written by
Monique Pittman
Pensions Expert

Monique Is Our Resident Pensions Expert. Many People Postpone Planning Out Their Pension, Thinking That Is Something They’ll Have to Worry Much Later in Life. Monique Knows How Important It Is to Start Planning Your Pension Early, and She Wants You to Know It Too!

Written by
Lisa Schilling
Insurance Expert

Lisa Is Our Resident Insurance Expert. She Knows How Important It Is to Be Ready for Any Scenario, Especially When a Family Member Is Involved. Nobody Likes Being Found Unprepared in a Tough Situation! Lisa Can Find the Best Insurance to Cover Your Every Need, Present and Future.

Doyle Edwards - 300x300

Written by
Doyle Edwards
Mortgages Expert

Doyle Is Our Resident Mortgages Expert. He Comes From a Long Line of Financial Gurus, and It Truly Shows. Despite His Young Age, There Is No Question He Cannot Answer When It Comes to Mortgages, and His Ability to See Outside of the Box to Find the Best Mortgage Deals Is Truly Impressive.

jason stubbs 300x300 1.jpg

Written by
Jason Stubbs
Equity Release Expert

Jason Stubbs Is a Specialist in the Equity Release Sector. He Enjoys Helping Older People Who Are Struggling Financially Get Out From Under Financial Pressure.

rachel w.jpg

Rachel Wait
Personal Finance Journalist

Rachel is an experienced finance journalist and editor with a particular interest in personal finance and consumer affairs. She has vast experience writing about money issues, property, insurance, and consumer affairs, and you’ll find her articles regularly featured in top media and newspaper publications.

Reviewed by
Francis Hui
Senior Risk Manager

Having held various high-level roles across the industry, Francis is truly an expert in aiding UK citizens in their financial decisions and risk analysis. His unique insight and statistical knowledge make him the perfect person to help you take your financial future to the next level.
Mark Patterson

Written by
Mark Patterson
Mortgage Expert

Mark Patterson is a well-known expert in mortgages. He has been working as an expert for over 15 years, and he specializes in the UK mortgage market.
kath icon.png

Katherine Read
Consumer Affairs Writer

She writes on the topics of equity release, home reversion, and mortgages.

Nicola Date

Nicola Date
Writer & Journalist

Nicola is a financial writer for EveryInvestor and is passionate about the opportunities that equity release can open up for homeowners. Her extensive business experience and deep understanding of the industry means that she’s always up-to-date with the latest developments.